I would NOT frog. I think it is lovely and could be inspirational of how quickly you "got it. Whatever you decide, I hope you post a pic of the completed work. 😊
Thanks so much! Will do… eventually, I‘m known for my unfinished projects 🥸
Hey everyone, this is my first double sided knit project.
I started this scarf a few weeks ago and had some ups and downs with it, the last 20-30 rows show where I finally „got it“ using a knitting thimble (never thought I‘d be using one but here I am) because I think the tension is pretty neat, the edge is consistent and at least the single colored parts of the scarf are actually two individual pieces, not tangled at all. In the beginning I somehow twisted the yarns the wrong way and ended up with a very sturdy seabass down there. The color changes still seem connected to each other up top so I can‘t pull the two layers apart completely, but I guess that‘s how you do it??
Anyway I just noticed that I left out a row by accident right where the leaf is, the pattern says the stem should be 2 stitches tall, not just one.
I‘m kinda devastated, because on the one side I really don‘t want to undo all my progress, frogging sucks!! But on the other hand I would be able to restart with better tension and a cleaner look overall since I have more knowledge about this technique now, and I‘m also a perfectionist so the thought of a missing row will haunt me forever, even if nobody knows about it except me. Also the pattern is now switched too and I’m afraid it might lead me to get confused following through the pattern. What would you do?
I highly appreciate your opinions and tips, wishing you a happy saturday! <3
I would NOT frog. I think it is lovely and could be inspirational of how quickly you "got it. Whatever you decide, I hope you post a pic of the completed work. 😊
Thanks so much! Will do… eventually, I‘m known for my unfinished projects 🥸
Personally, I think you have done fantastic work and should not frog. I think you could duplicate stitch it in on both sides after. Keep moving forward with the fantastic work!
Thanks so much for your kind words! I still need to figure out the duplicate stitch, will be looking into that!
Two quotes that might help you make your decision: “If it (the mistake) can’t be seen from the back of a galloping horse…” <widely attributed to Elizabeth Zimmerman> “Only Allah/God is perfect…” Sometimes one or both of these helps me.
Love the first one haha, that‘s what I‘m trying to tell myself too!
I love that EZ quote and have whispered it oftem.
Don't frog right away. Cast on with two new balls of yarn and restart the project. Seeing the new version come out so much neater and better often makes frogging a lot less painful. And if you realise early on it doesn't really get that much better you can still go back and keep knitting the one with all the progress.
Love this idea! Unfortunately I only have two spools for my yarn holder and I will definitely not knit without it, I haven‘t had the hustle of twisting yarns since working with this thing but you can‘t buy single spools. But you‘re right, looking at the new neater version eases the pain of frogging :D
Leaf? I don't recognize a leaf but neither can I see a missing stitch. Everything looks great to me. If that is the only consequence of the missing row, then don't frog it. This is one of those times when only you know there was a error. You might not even notice or remember it yourself in a few weeks or months. Keep working forward you're making great progress.
The leaf is the shape above the balloon, it’s a logo from the game this design is featuring. I understand how you feel but I agree, would not frog. You could duplicate stitch the missing leaf stem if you really wanted to but I would leave it.
Oh so nice to see animal crossing here!
That’s adorable! Is this pattern on Ravelry?
Thanks!! Forgot to mention, yes it‘s available on Ravelry. Search for Animal Neighborhood Scarf, don‘t wanna piss off big brands for sure 🙂↕️
The pattern creator is Katharina Kuntz. You can follow her on Instagram too. I’m currently working on the over the garden wall scarf she made 😀
This is adorable! I get what you're saying but i wouldn't frog it. It's too cute!!
Absolutely not! It’s fantastic.
Thank you so much! <3
My first double knitting project was also a scarf, a star wars scarf. You can definitely see a progression in how good I was at it in the beginning and at the end. I personally love that. I wouldn't frog this, I think it's beautiful
Yeah I get what you mean, having the progress visible makes it even more unique. Star Wars scarf sounds awesome!!
I think its cute. But the question is, would u wear it? If the answer is yes, then please keep it because it's cute and some beautiful double knit has happened.
Thank you! I‘d absolutely wear it right now, that‘s a good question to decide about the frogging :D I‘ll keep that, thanks!
Don't frog it but do share the pattern omg
The pattern is called Animal Neighborhood Scarf on Ravelry. You can design it yourself with all the characters, decorations etc. It‘s awesome
I’m in the same predicament - I am doing the Hero of Generations scarf, and I definitely messed up a couple of rows between row 1 - 50 before it kinda “clicked” for me. However, I know nobody will notice once I am wearing the scarf, so I would not frog. Sure it annoys me a bit looking at the master sword looking a bit lopsided, but once it is done, nobody will notice. I didn’t notice your mistakes before you pointed them out since I haven’t tried to knit this scarf.
Yeah that sounds reasonable. I hope once it‘s blocked everything wonky will even out and the ✨ happy little accidents ✨ make it special!
I’m not even seeing where the problem is so I think it’s fine. As others have said you can duplicate-stitch it on if it’s bothering you. The whole point of double knitting is that you can’t separate the layers.
Thanks! Yeah I see that you need to twist the yarn at the edges so the two fabrics don‘t separate, but before I started I thought you would create two separate wobbly pieces of fabric that only hold onto each other at the edges (if that‘s understandable) like with floats in between, but now that I‘ve knit and thought about it I see that I was totally wrong here 😅
Please, I understand the perfection gremlin. I understand it so well, but this looks almost perfect, especially from any reasonable distance don’t do it. Finish this and do something else and it’ll be even better and that’s the curse and blessing of art everything you make is better than the last time so you always know that you’re making it worse than you could do. It’s better to finish something.
This TED talk almost made me cry, thank you <3 I‘ll keep knitting it, considering how much time it took and that it only shows the process even more!
consider washing and blocking what you've made so far, with the needle in and all. The tension may not be as noticeable then and it might make the decision easier
This is such a good idea, thank you!! Will do that tomorrow so it can dry in the sun a little quicker and I can keep working on it hehe
Omg how do you do designs like this with knitting is it like a specific kind of stitch or what? this is so cool!!!! I’m a beginner still but I want to move onto more advanced stuff soon l would appreciate any tips or info on how to make something like this !!! :)
Look up “double knitting,” basically you knit two stitches for each one (one front and one back), making the project twice as long, but it’s so worth it when done since your work will be double sided!
This is so charming!
I dont see a leaf, I see a couch. :) If it really bothers you just duplicate stitch over the top stitch
I’m currently doing the OTGW scarf by the same person and I’ve made SO many mistakes but I keep making them and if I frogged every time, I would never get it done. It’s also a gift but that’s the beauty of something hand made! As long as you can keep track of your rows after missing a row, I wouldn’t frog it. Maybe start using lifelines? I’ve done that just incase!
I am reaching the end of my own double knit scarf (the legend of zelda one) and I think I have gone back and duplicate stitched like 10 stitches. you literally cannot tell where they were so I would say just do that. anywhere there are color changes the work will be connected, it should be able to pull apart in areas where it only one color per side. also I don't think your tension is bad at all!
Dude I am team frog like 90% of the time. Knitted an entire sweater but not digging how dense it was? Frog that thang. Not super stoked by the pattern anymore? Byeeeee. I usually have these projects bagged for a few months and when I go back I feel less attachment and NEVER regret frogging. I have started many projects over I’ve made substantial progress on and am always glad I did. That said - I will tell you in this case I ABSOLUTELY would not frog. This looks amazing and you haven’t even blocked it yet. What I have also noticed with dozens of projects is that when I make a few mistakes that really bother me while I’m in the process of knitting (like missing a stitch or whatever in a colorwork pattern), as soon as the project is done, I suddenly do not care. Like my favorite sweater has a small coffee stain right smack dab in the middle of the back (the sweater is white). Do I wear it almost everyday anyway? Yes. Did it bother the crap out of me while I was knitting? Yes, I just prayed it would come out when I washed it. (It didn’t.) Your tension issues are not visible to my eye and this amount of work is truly not worth redoing for whatever you are noticing in the moment right now. This looks sick, definitely post an update when you’re done!!!
You sound like me right now lol. As soon as I feel like I've gotten the hang of a project, I scrap it and start over. If you really feel like you wanna tackle it again, go for it. Sometimes it's more about the process itself than the end result.
I'm working on the same scarf! I also completed my other (much simpler) double knit project, and it's very obvious the difference in tension from the beginning to the end. For what it's worth, 1) it mostly blocked out and 2) I think it's fun seeing my improvement. And as someone who knows what you are working on, visually it's not obvious that you are missing a row. I would not frog it personally!