Personally, I’d do Tavarua.
tavarua is the dream, no question. cloudbreak on a good day is something else entirely. if you're really trying to go all out, look into one of the private boat charters through the mentawais too, they'll put you on perfect waves with way fewer people
Tavarua doesn’t offer much for a non-water sport partner. If you wanna do Cloudbreak, stay at Momi bay resort. You can still get a boat to Cloudbreak it just takes a bit longer than coming from Tavarua.
I would not do tavarua. It’s pretty fickle and when it’s fun size it gets crowded now that it’s not exclusive.
Especially if you’re goofy
Musket cove is really nice. Easy boats to cloudbreak and restaurants and other breaks. Great resort nice restaurant for wife. Hiking, amazing beach.