Is it possible to climb Mount Everest (or any 8,000m peak) on a pure water fast? Has anyone ever tried it, and what would it mean for human limits?

Комментарии

• u/laetecaedus·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:22

  No you would run out of glycogen stores exerting that kind of effort without consuming calories.

• u/RenRen512·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:32

  As they burned upwards of 10,000 calories a day—20,000 on a summit attempt—they struggled to get enough sustenance. -- Bon Appetit

• u/areallymanlyman·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:32

  The next person who pisses me off, I will tell them to climb Mount Everest on a waterfast and die. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

• u/Big-Bumbaclart·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:35

  Whoever said there is no such thing as a stupid question was just proved wrong.

• u/AlienSquatch·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:40

  OP Are you high or? You’d die

• u/festermcseptic·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:40

  How the fuck have we survived as a species

• u/Adventurous_Jello152·1·1 авг. 2026 г., 12:55

  "Impossible is just an opinion, not a fact" – A Reply to the Skeptics Many people forget that the greatest milestones in sports, science, and human performance all started with a question that the majority of contemporaries labeled as "stupid" or "impossible." When we question our current physiological limits, we aren't looking at today’s reality; we are looking at the borderline where current science ends and the next step of human evolution begins. History is filled with "impossible" walls that were eventually shattered into pieces:

  1. Historical & Physical Breakthroughs • Reinhold Messner and the Lack of Oxygen (1978): Before Reinhold Messner and Peter Habeler climbed Everest without supplemental oxygen, the international medical community unanimously claimed it was physiologically impossible. They stated that the human brain would die without oxygen at that altitude, leading to immediate death or permanent brain damage. Messner proved the medical establishment wrong. • Eddie Hall and the 500 kg Deadlift (2016): Experts researching the capacity of the human spine and musculature believed that moving half a ton from the ground was past the breaking point of human anatomy. When Eddie Hall lifted the 500 kg, blood vessels burst in his head from the internal pressure, but he did it—completely rewriting what we knew about maximum musculoskeletal strength. • Usain Bolt and the 9.58 Seconds (2009): Biomechanical researchers previously used mathematical models to "prove" that the human body, due to bone and tendon density, was incapable of running 100 meters faster than 9.60 seconds. Usain Bolt not only broke this record but practically laughed past a supposedly absolute scientific limit. • The 4-Minute Mile (1954): For decades, doctors genuinely believed that if a human ran a mile under 4 minutes, their heart would literally explode from the strain. Roger Bannister did it anyway in 1954. Once he showed it was possible, 24 other runners achieved the exact same feat within the following year—because the barrier wasn't in their bodies, it was in their minds. • Diana Nyad’s Ocean Swim (2013): At 64 years old, she swam from Cuba to Florida (110 miles) without a shark cage through open, box-jellyfish-infested waters. She failed five times, and experts claimed that due to her age and ocean currents, the mission was biologically impossible. She completed it anyway. • Aviation and Space Travel: Lord Kelvin, President of the Royal Society, famously stated in 1895 that "heavier-than-air flying machines are impossible." Eight years later, the Wright brothers took flight. When space travel was first proposed, critics called it "madness," claiming vacuum and radiation would instantly kill a human. Today, a permanent crew lives on the International Space Station.

  ───

  1. The Cellular Biology: Why the Question is Scientifically Fascinating Contrary to casual internet commentators, modern biochemistry and aerospace medicine heavily investigate the relationship between fasting and hypoxia (oxygen deprivation). If someone were to attempt a pure water fast at 8,000 meters, two extreme processes would collide in their body, yielding fascinating scientific questions: • The Fat-Adaptation and Glucose Paradox: At high altitudes, the human body fundamentally shifts to burning carbohydrates (glucose) because carbohydrates require less oxygen to process than fats. A pure water fast forces the body into deep ketosis (burning fat). A climber succeeding under these conditions would prove that human cells can develop a previously unknown, ultra-efficient, fat-based oxygen utilization pathway under extreme hypoxia. • mTOR Inhibition and ATP Preservation: Recent cellular studies published in Nature show that fasting dramatically increases cell survival during extreme oxygen deprivation. Fasting downregulates a protein complex called mTOR, which halts non-essential cellular processes and lowers the body's baseline oxygen and energy requirements (ATP consumption). On a cellular level, fasting actually protects tissues from suffocating. • Overriding the Central Governor: When athletes break absolute records, they bypass the brain's safety brakes (the central governor and the Golgi tendon organ reflex) that normally shut down muscles to prevent self-injury. A water-fasted summit would require a level of alignment between evolutionary survival mode (autophagy) and sheer willpower that essentially defines a structurally new type of human performance. Conclusion: According to current science, the 6,000 to 8,000-calorie daily burn in the Death Zone would consume muscle mass and cause a fatal drop in blood sugar without external fuel. But if we never ask questions that push these boundaries, we will never find out what the human body is truly capable of when forced to its absolute edge. Before Roger Bannister, the 4-minute mile was just a "stupid, life-threatening idea" too.